A Pizza Delivery – Starfish Door Puzzle and Open Sesame Achievement & Trophy Guide

Welcome to our guide for A Pizza Delivery, available on PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S, and on Steam. This guide will tell you how to get the Open Sesame achievement or trophy for opening the starfish door.

Check out our A Pizza Delivery review for our full thoughts on the game.

This guide contains early-game spoilers.


Open Sesame Achievement and Trophy Guide

This is part of the game’s natural progression early on. Once you have completed the opening area, you will drive through a tunnel, and then the game will distort as you enter a dark area. The phone will be ringing in front of you, answering is optional, and can impact one of the following two achievements/trophies:

  • Total Disconnection – Ignore all phone calls
  • Always Available – Answer all of Earl’s calls

Stay on your bike and follow the road until you reach some steps where Noby sits atop. You can talk to Noby if you wish; doing so is required for various other achievements, including all memories, delivering all pizzas, and the ‘Noby’ achievement/trophy for helping Noby get back home.

If you don’t speak to Noby, you can work towards the ‘No Delivery’ achievement/trophy for not delivering any pizza.

Pass by Noby and continue to the right, where you can drive down a small slope with a hand statue in front of you. From there, look right where you can see a child’s playground. Head up to the playground to grab the starfish here:

Now you have the starfish, you need to start a short journey back towards the start of the stage. Get back on your bike and go past Noby. Stick to the road, and shortly after, on the right, you’ll see this alleyway with the door you’re about to open:

Walk up to the door, and B will place the starfish into the slot. You now have to turn the key left and right in a pattern to open. Here’s the command:

  • Left, right, right, left, right

And with that, the door will open, and you will unlock your Open Sesame achievement/trophy. Behind the door is a lever you’ll need to progress to the next section of the game. Congratulations!


That has been our Open Sesame achievement/trophy guide. We hope you found it helpful. For more guides, stick with Gamer Social Club, and consider joining our friendly and growing Gamer Social Club Discord!

Mark "WeAwokenTheHive" Pell

I'm Mark! Lifelong nerd and Xbot, with a soft spot for Nintendo. Favourite games of all time include SM64, Elden Ring and Call of Duty Warzone 1 (RIP). When I'm not being a dad or gaming, I'm watching football (or soccer, if you will!).Over on Twitter I can be found @Core_Xbox.

Share This Article

A Pizza Delivery – Starfish Door Puzzle and Open Sesame Achievement & Trophy Guide

Mark "WeAwokenTheHive" Pell

I'm Mark! Lifelong nerd and Xbot, with a soft spot for Nintendo. Favourite games of all time include SM64, Elden Ring and Call of Duty Warzone 1 (RIP). When I'm not being a dad or gaming, I'm watching football (or soccer, if you will!).Over on Twitter I can be found @Core_Xbox.

Recomended Posts

PowerWash Simulator 2 – Spin Doctor Achievement/Trophy Guide

Some brave members of The GSC have grabbed their gumboots and power washers to help guide you through the filthy…

Mafia: The Old Country – Rare Weapons Expert Achievement Guide

Make a name for yourself Carusu, become a Rare Weapon Expert with our tips and tricks guide for Mafia: The…

Elden Ring Nightreign Update to Boost Solo Adventurers

Let Me Solo Her takes on a whole new meaning?…